There will be a by-election for the Victorian state seat of Prahran coming up soon, likely at the start of 2025.
Sam Hibbins won the seat for the Greens in 2014, and again in 2018 and 2022. He quit the party earlier this month after revelations of an affair with a staff member.
The seat is an unusual one – when Hibbins first won in 2014, the race between Greens and Labor for second place was extremely close, and it was also very close between the Greens and Liberals for the two-candidate-preferred count. Indeed it was so close that the Liberal Party would have won a race against Labor if they had made it to the final count.
The Greens-Labor race remained very close in 2018, but the Liberal Party fell behind. Hibbins won comfortably on both axes in 2022. But in his absence, this race could be interesting on either measure.
Prior to 2023, there had never been a sitting Greens MP elected to a single-member seat at a state or federal election (not counting by-elections) who had retired or been defeated. Jamie Parker retired in 2023, and the Greens retained his seat of Balmain despite a large swing. And then Amy MacMahon lost her seat of South Brisbane. But this is the first time a Greens MP has resigned mid-term to create a by-election.
Read my guide to Prahran here.
I believe all 3 main parties will contest, as well as AJP and Socialists on the Left and at least 2 minor on the right.
The Greens have a strong presense and should win. I think their main issue will be the Israel/Palestine conflict and the ALP long time in office.
I am going 90% Green or ALP at this point.
Green retain with reduced margin.
The Greens would struggle if the three main parties contested. Sam Hibbins’s personal vote is now gone. Oftentimes there might be a sense of shame or remorse when an MP leaves due to bad behaviour or allegations of it. There’s also the Israel issue. The St Kilda East and Balaclava parts have large Jewish communities. The Israel issue is the Greens’s kryptonite.
The wild card is whether Michelle Ananda-Rajah (whose federal seat here just got abolished) will run.
I alluded to these in the by-election guide.
https://www.tallyroom.com.au/prahranby2025