Victorian federal redistribution – final margins

8

The AEC released the final maps and data for the Victorian federal redistribution earlier today. In this blog post I’m going to post my final estimates of primary votes, two-party-preferred and two-candidate-preferred margins for each seat. At the end I’ve also posted the final pendulum after the completion of the redistributions in New South Wales, Victoria and Western Australia, although we have the draft boundaries for the NT redistribution due tomorrow.

First up, this map shows the changes between the 2022 boundaries, the draft 2025 boundaries and the final boundaries for Victoria.

As we found out in early September, only nine seats have experienced any change compared to the draft boundaries: Ballarat, Bendigo, Chisholm, Corangamite, Hotham, McEwen, Nicholls, Scullin, Wannon.

You can see this in the margins, because the changes are mostly very small. The Labor margin in Bendigo is cut from 12.1% in 2022, to 12.0% in the draft, to 11.2% in the final version. The Nationals margin in Nicholls drops from 2.5% to 2.3%, and Labor’s margin in McEwen increases from 3.4% to 3.8%. Labor’s margin in Scullin is also up from 15.3% to 15.5%. All the other changes are barely perceptible.

The pendulum is very similar to the one I posted after the draft boundaries were published for NSW in June. In net terms the ALP and Coalition remain on 77 and 58 respectively, with the number of crossbench seats cut from 16 to 15 with the loss of North Sydney. None of the swing-to-win calculations I used there have changed.

Estimates of two-candidate-preferred margins

Seat Old margin New margin
Aston LIB 2.8% LIB 2.6%
Ballarat ALP 13.0% ALP 13.0%
Bendigo ALP 12.1% ALP 12.0%
Bruce ALP 6.6% ALP 5.3%
Calwell ALP 12.4% ALP 12.4%
Casey LIB 1.5% LIB 1.4%
Chisholm ALP 6.4% ALP 3.3%
Cooper ALP vs GRN 8.7% ALP vs GRN 7.8%
Corangamite ALP 7.6% ALP 7.8%
Corio ALP 12.8% ALP 12.5%
Deakin LIB 0.2% LIB 0.0%
Dunkley ALP 6.3% ALP 6.8%
Flinders LIB 6.7% LIB 6.2%
Fraser ALP 16.5% ALP 16.6%
Gellibrand ALP 11.5% ALP 11.2%
Gippsland NAT 20.6% NAT 20.6%
Goldstein IND vs LIB 2.9% IND vs LIB 3.9%
Gorton ALP 10.0% ALP 10.0%
Hawke ALP 7.6% ALP 7.6%
Higgins (abolished) ALP 2.1%
Holt ALP 7.1% ALP 7.1%
Hotham ALP 14.3% ALP 11.6%
Indi IND vs LIB 8.9% IND vs LIB 8.9%
Isaacs ALP 6.9% ALP 9.5%
Jagajaga ALP 12.3% ALP 12.2%
Kooyong IND vs LIB 2.9% IND vs LIB 3.5%
La Trobe LIB 8.7% LIB 8.4%
Lalor ALP 12.8% ALP 12.8%
Macnamara ALP 12.2% ALP 12.2%
Mallee NAT 19.0% NAT 19.0%
Maribyrnong ALP 12.4% ALP 13.0%
McEwen ALP 3.3% ALP 3.4%
Melbourne GRN vs ALP 10.2% GRN vs ALP 6.9%
Menzies LIB 0.7% ALP 0.4%
Monash LIB 2.9% LIB 2.9%
Nicholls NAT vs IND 3.8% NAT vs IND 2.5%
Scullin ALP 15.6% ALP 15.3%
Wannon LIB vs IND 3.9% LIB vs IND 3.4%
Wills ALP vs GRN 8.6% ALP vs GRN 4.6%

Estimates of vote share for final electoral boundaries

Seat ALP 2PP LIB 2PP ALP prim LNP prim GRN prim IND prim
Aston 47.4 52.6 32.5 42.8 12.2 0.1
Ballarat 63.0 37.0 44.8 27.1 14.6 2.1
Bendigo 61.2 38.8 42.1 27.3 13.8 4.7
Bruce 55.3 44.7 40.3 31.7 9.7 0.2
Calwell 62.4 37.6 44.9 23.7 9.8 0.0
Casey 48.6 51.4 25.1 36.6 13.1 11.4
Chisholm 53.3 46.7 34.8 39.2 14.1 4.0
Cooper 75.7 24.3 40.7 16.2 28.4 0.0
Corangamite 57.9 42.2 38.4 34.0 15.3 0.0
Corio 62.5 37.5 41.9 25.0 14.7 0.1
Deakin 50.0 50.0 32.9 41.5 14.2 1.1
Dunkley 56.8 43.2 40.5 31.7 10.6 3.4
Flinders 43.8 56.2 22.8 43.3 9.5 11.7
Fraser 66.6 33.4 42.1 24.5 18.9 0.0
Gellibrand 61.2 38.8 42.8 27.2 15.6 0.3
Gippsland 29.4 70.6 19.2 54.1 8.5 0.0
Goldstein 46.3 53.7 13.6 39.6 8.4 31.3
Gorton 60.0 40.0 41.3 27.4 9.0 2.5
Hawke 57.6 42.4 36.7 26.4 8.9 7.9
Holt 57.1 42.9 40.8 29.5 8.6 3.0
Hotham 61.6 38.4 43.1 28.6 14.7 0.3
Indi 44.7 55.3 8.6 34.3 3.6 40.7
Isaacs 59.5 40.5 42.8 29.5 12.1 0.0
Jagajaga 62.2 37.8 40.8 29.2 16.7 3.0
Kooyong 46.3 53.7 11.3 43.4 9.9 31.0
La Trobe 41.6 58.4 26.2 45.2 10.9 0.0
Lalor 62.8 37.2 44.1 25.0 10.4 2.8
Macnamara 62.2 37.8 31.7 29.1 29.7 1.9
Mallee 31.0 69.0 16.8 49.1 5.3 12.2
Maribyrnong 63.0 37.0 42.2 26.8 16.7 0.0
McEwen 53.8 46.2 37.2 32.7 14.1 0.0
Melbourne 73.1 26.9 25.7 19.5 44.7 1.0
Menzies 50.4 49.6 31.8 41.0 12.9 4.9
Monash 47.1 52.9 25.6 37.8 9.9 10.7
Nicholls 34.2 65.8 13.2 43.4 3.7 24.1
Scullin 65.5 34.5 46.3 21.7 10.9 0.0
Wannon 41.4 58.7 19.6 44.2 6.7 20.9
Wills 77.1 22.9 36.4 16.2 32.8 0.2

Pendulum

 

Labor Seats Coalition Seats
Seat Margin Seat Margin
Gilmore (NSW) ALP 0.2% Deakin (VIC) LIB 0.0%
Menzies (VIC) ALP 0.4% Bennelong (NSW) LIB 0.1%
Lyons (TAS) ALP 0.9% Sturt (SA) LIB 0.5%
Lingiari (NT) ALP 0.9% Moore (WA) LIB 0.9%
Robertson (NSW) ALP 2.2% Canning (WA) LIB 1.2%
Paterson (NSW) ALP 2.6% Casey (VIC) LIB 1.4%
Tangney (WA) ALP 2.8% Bass (TAS) LIB 1.4%
Boothby (SA) ALP 3.3% Dickson (QLD) LNP 1.7%
Bullwinkel (WA) ALP 3.3% Nicholls (VIC) NAT 2.3% vs IND
Chisholm (VIC) ALP 3.3% Cowper (NSW) NAT 2.4% vs IND
Parramatta (NSW) ALP 3.7% Bradfield (NSW) LIB 2.5%
McEwen (VIC) ALP 3.8% Aston (VIC) LIB 2.6%
Wills (VIC) ALP 4.6% vs GRN Banks (NSW) LIB 2.6%
Hunter (NSW) ALP 4.8% Monash (VIC) LIB 2.9%
Reid (NSW) ALP 5.2% Longman (QLD) LNP 3.1%
Blair (QLD) ALP 5.2% Bonner (QLD) LNP 3.4%
Bruce (VIC) ALP 5.3% Leichhardt (QLD) LNP 3.4%
Werriwa (NSW) ALP 5.3% Hughes (NSW) LIB 3.5%
Shortland (NSW) ALP 6.0% Wannon (VIC) NAT 3.5% vs IND
Eden-Monaro (NSW) ALP 6.1% Flynn (QLD) LNP 3.8%
Macquarie (NSW) ALP 6.3% Forrest (WA) LIB 4.2%
Dobell (NSW) ALP 6.6% Forde (QLD) LNP 4.2%
Dunkley (VIC) ALP 6.8% Petrie (QLD) LNP 4.4%
Holt (VIC) ALP 7.1% Durack (WA) LIB 4.7%
Hawke (VIC) ALP 7.6% Bowman (QLD) LNP 5.5%
Cooper (VIC) ALP 7.8% vs GRN Lindsay (NSW) LIB 6.1%
Corangamite (VIC) ALP 7.9% Flinders (VIC) LIB 6.2%
Greenway (NSW) ALP 8.0% Capricornia (QLD) LNP 6.6%
Richmond (NSW) ALP 8.2% O’Connor (WA) LIB 6.7%
Whitlam (NSW) ALP 8.3% Hume (NSW) LIB 6.9%
Pearce (WA) ALP 8.8% Groom (QLD) LNP 6.9% vs IND
Hindmarsh (SA) ALP 8.9% Berowra (NSW) LIB 7.5%
Rankin (QLD) ALP 9.1% Braddon (TAS) LIB 8.0%
Moreton (QLD) ALP 9.1% La Trobe (VIC) LIB 8.4%
Solomon (NT) ALP 9.4% Fisher (QLD) LNP 8.7%
Swan (WA) ALP 9.4% Fairfax (QLD) LNP 9.0%
Isaacs (VIC) ALP 9.5% McPherson (QLD) LNP 9.3%
Macarthur (NSW) ALP 9.8% Calare (NSW) NAT 9.7% vs IND
Cowan (WA) ALP 9.9% Riverina (NSW) NAT 9.7%
Gorton (VIC) ALP 10.0% Grey (SA) LIB 10.1%
Hasluck (WA) ALP 10.1% Hinkler (QLD) LNP 10.1%
McMahon (NSW) ALP 10.5% Dawson (QLD) LNP 10.4%
Lilley (QLD) ALP 10.5% Mitchell (NSW) LIB 10.5%
Makin (SA) ALP 10.8% Fadden (QLD) LNP 10.6%
Gellibrand (VIC) ALP 11.2% Page (NSW) NAT 10.7%
Bendigo (VIC) ALP 11.2% Wright (QLD) LNP 10.9%
Hotham (VIC) ALP 11.6% Moncrieff (QLD) LNP 11.2%
Oxley (QLD) ALP 11.6% Wide Bay (QLD) LNP 11.3%
Adelaide (SA) ALP 11.9% Cook (NSW) LIB 11.7%
Barton (NSW) ALP 12.0% Herbert (QLD) LNP 11.8%
Macnamara (VIC) ALP 12.2% Lyne (NSW) NAT 13.8%
Canberra (ACT) ALP 12.2% vs GRN New England (NSW) NAT 15.2%
Jagajaga (VIC) ALP 12.2% Farrer (NSW) LIB 16.4%
Calwell (VIC) ALP 12.4% Barker (SA) LIB 16.6%
Corio (VIC) ALP 12.5% Parkes (NSW) NAT 18.1%
Lalor (VIC) ALP 12.8% Mallee (VIC) NAT 19.0%
Spence (SA) ALP 12.9% Gippsland (VIC) NAT 20.6%
Bean (ACT) ALP 12.9% Maranoa (QLD) LNP 22.1%
Ballarat (VIC) ALP 13.0%
Blaxland (NSW) ALP 13.0%
Maribyrnong (VIC) ALP 13.0%
Burt (WA) ALP 13.3%
Kingsford Smith (NSW) ALP 13.3% Curtin (WA) IND 1.3% vs LIB
Chifley (NSW) ALP 13.6% Fowler (NSW) IND 1.4% vs ALP
Franklin (TAS) ALP 13.7% Ryan (QLD) GRN 2.6% vs LNP
Perth (WA) ALP 14.4% Mackellar (NSW) IND 3.3% vs LIB
Cunningham (NSW) ALP 15.1% Kooyong (VIC) IND 3.5% vs LIB
Watson (NSW) ALP 15.2% Brisbane (QLD) GRN 3.7% vs LNP
Scullin (VIC) ALP 15.5% Goldstein (VIC) IND 3.9% vs LIB
Fenner (ACT) ALP 15.7% Melbourne (VIC) GRN 6.9% vs ALP
Kingston (SA) ALP 16.4% Indi (VIC) IND 8.9% vs LIB
Sydney (NSW) ALP 16.5% vs GRN Wentworth (NSW) IND 9.0% vs LIB
Fraser (VIC) ALP 16.6% Warringah (NSW) IND 9.4% vs LIB
Fremantle (WA) ALP 16.9% Griffith (QLD) GRN 10.5% vs LNP
Brand (WA) ALP 17.1% Mayo (SA) CA 12.3% vs LIB
Grayndler (NSW) ALP 17.4% vs GRN Kennedy (QLD) KAP 13.1% vs LNP
Newcastle (NSW) ALP 17.9% Clark (TAS) IND 20.8% vs ALP
Liked it? Take a second to support the Tally Room on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!

8 COMMENTS

  1. There should be fixed 4 year term elections. The Albanese government was elected may 2022 and should go to an election in approx may 25. I am sure it will be so

  2. Is anyone else not that impressed by these boundaries, maybe i’m not been practical enough or we’ve been spoilt with boundaries in recent years that have to change due to each division needing to contain a greater amount of people but i think if some of these boundaries continue we might see a bigger push for expanding the house.
    Melbourne: Don’t really see the point of losing Fitzroy North and adding South Yarra unless Wills needed voters (although it did contract a little bit). I guess South Yarra had to move due to Higgin abolition and didn’t quite fit in with other seats, don’t think it would’ve been too out of place in Macnamara though.

    Macnamara: Thought this would be a good chance to fix the tail with Higgins abolition but it might’ve got skipped over with other worries such as the eastern Melbourne boundaries.

    Menzies: Really don’t see the point in removing North Warrandyte and adding it to Jagajaga, it doesn’t provide a large amount of voters to fix any quota issues and is only really connected to Eltham, Research and Kangaroo Ground. It’s a satellite suburb of Warrandyte and shares many interests with the suburb of Warrandyte.
    Box Hill and Blackburn make sense with Doncaster and Warrandyte and Doncaster make sense but i don’t think Box and Hill, Blackburn and Warrandyte make too much sense, i guess this is the result of larger divisions though and there’s not much else they can do.

    Deakin: Park Orchards fits in well with most of the seat, not sure how well it fits in with the suburbs south of the Eastlink though.
    Not a massive fan of splitting Donvale although the two sides are a bit different i guess in terms of feel.
    This seat will be intersting because it’s added strong liberal areas in Park Orchards and Donvale but the margin hasn’t changed, i guess they’re not as populated as other suburbs maybe but Sukkar should be safe if he gets swings in these area and minimises swings against in other areas.

    Casey: Wonga Park been with Chirnside Park makes sense, been in the same division as the rest of the seat not so much. Does seem like a hard area to do boundaries for though.

    Chisolm: Not too sure about this, can anyone let me know if Malvern East and Glen Iris make sense been in the same seat as Glen Waverley.

  3. @north east I think big has about 1/2 a chance of regaining it’s 39th seat after the next election so that would be a good time to fix them up

  4. I don’t have too much of a problem with Malvern East, Glen Iris and Glen Waverley being in the same seat because they are all along the Glen Waverley Line corridor. Generally I think seats focused on a particular train line work pretty well.

    Of course, Hotham is a different story. While it’s focused on the Pakenham/Cranbourne lines, it’s hard to see how Murrumbeena and Noble Park share any community of interest whatsoever.

    But the stretch of Glen Waverley Line from Malvern East / Darling through to Glen Waverley doesn’t have the dramatic demographic changes that the Pakenham/Cranbourne line has so I think it works ok. Certainly better than Malvern East being in Hotham as per the original draft.

  5. For anyone interested, the gazetted enrolment for October has been released:
    https://www.aec.gov.au/Enrolling_to_vote/Enrolment_stats/gazetted/2024/10.htm

    The only real problem division is Gorton, which is already at +5.80% enrolment deviation and appears to be the fastest growing division in the state. Not quite sure why the ABS projections thought that this division was going to remain stable.

    Melbourne and Macnamara are also interesting as they are far lower on enrolment than expected (-5.61% and -4.86%), possibly due to the large presence of non-citizens in the inner city. Sydney appears to be the same.

    The 21 divisions in the North and West of the state are currently slightly underenrolled, making up 20.85 quotas. Based on long term trends, they’ll reach 21 quotas roughly 2 years from now.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here